What Our Clients Think

Write a Review
zillow review

Carol is always right on top of everything. Her knowledge of listings and the area is vast, but it's the care and dedication she puts into her clients needs and wants that really jumps out! She truly wants the people she works with to find the best place possible and find a home they can be happy and comfortable in. When it comes to selling a home, she goes above and beyond to make it as easy as possible. There's no stress through the process with Carol!

dkochanny

02/25/2020

zillow review

Carol is very knowledgeable and easy to work with. She always had time for my questions and made the house buying and selling process seem effortless.

mheinzel

03/26/2019

zillow review

Carol was kind, helpful and very knowledgeable. She handled the specific issues with the sale of our property in a timely and professional manner. She gave us the appropriate advice/information as things progressed in the selling process. We would definitely recommend Carol Fay.

comasiba3

06/13/2015

zillow review

Carol was an integral part of the sale of my condo. I've worked with Carol on the sale/purchase of 3 homes. She is the epitome of professionalism and knowledge. She gives sound advice and we had an offer in just 3 weeks!! I would highly recommend Carol as 'your' realtor.

LeaSimpson

02/04/2015

zillow review

Carol is very good at what she does! She’s hard working and Honest! She helped with the sale of our home and with the purchase of our new home, it seemed as if she were working 24/7! Honest and caring best describes her!

m dbanach

02/25/2020

zillow review

Carol Fay, located in Petoskey MI, assisted us with selling our house during the winter of 2015-16. She had helped us to sell a house in the past, and as that experience was quite good, we didn't even think twice about going to her again. We asked Carol to come over to assess what preliminary work should be done in order to put the house on the market; she gave good advice, and knew of local handymen to help us with those projects, if necessary. As we were selling the house from long-distance, there were several occasions when we couldn't be there to see to something, such as turning off the water after a showing (or turning it back on), checking the house to determine if we were on track in readying it for sale, keeping us informed as to the snowplowing of the driveway, etc. When the time came to negotiate on the sale itself, Carol gave excellent advice on how to proceed next. At every step along the way, Carol was responsive in a timely manner and had good, positive ideas as to the next step. There is a reason why she has such a fine reputation in the area as a realtor, and she has worked hard and consistently to earn it.

kjartist9

02/25/2016

zillow review

Carol demonstrated her expertise and experience in selling homes through out the entire process, from listing the house to closing. Carol provided good counsel throughout the selling process, which was very much appreciated. She communicated effectively responding to our questions in a very timely manner. If I was selling or buying another house in the Petoskey area I would go to her! Great job Carol. Thank You!

mjgohlke

06/07/2015

zillow review

Carol is not only a terrific Realtor, she is a terrific person. Her personality turns every client into a friend. She is always upbeat and positive. She knows everything about the area, and has an excellent reputation. She really cares about her clients. She sold us a house and then sold our condo, and always went the extra mile.

zuser20160329084136766

02/25/2020

zillow review

I was refereed to Carol by a friend and I can see why. She did an outstanding job helping my wife and I find our home. Moving from a different town it was wonderful to have a realtor that was so knowledgeable about the community as well as the housing market. She did an excellent job with negotiations as well as keeping me informed along the way. I will never use another real estate professional.

zuser20150805181532749

02/17/2016

zillow review

Carol was key to our being able to purchase our new home in Emmett County. she was knowledgable, supportive, professional and extremely enjoyable to work with. I would recommend her to anyone and will certainly use her again if need for a realtor arises.

Kelly Newton

04/27/2015

Get Top Dollar for Your Home With Our 100+ Point Marketing Plan!

Learn how we will get your home:

  • In front of and shown to more buyers
  • Sold faster and for more money
  • Sold on your terms without the hassle and stress

Seller & Buyer Guides for You!

Popular Guides for Home Buyers

See More

Popular Guides for Home Owners

See More

When do you plan to buy? We can help!

Take the first step by getting a FREE report with all the answers to your questions.Enter your zip code below to get ALL the information in less than 60 Seconds!

Female Agent

What type of property do you plan to buy?

When do you plan to buy?

How would you rate your credit score?

Is this your first property purchase?

How will this property be used?

What is the estimated purchase price of your next home?

$120,000   to   $500,000

What is your estimated down payment?

5% Down

Zero Down

More Than 50% Down

What is your gross annual household income?

$25,000 to $45,000

More Than $250,000

$0 to $25,000

What is your employment status?

Are you working with a real estate agent?

What is your full name and email?

or use your Facebook instead

What is your phone number?

By providing your phone number to receive this free information, you accept our Terms of Use and acknowledge your personal data will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. You agree that we may contact you at the telephone number you provided, including if your number is on a Do Not Call list.

Carol Fay
Carol Fay

Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realtors, 420 Howard St, Petoskey, MI 49770

Licensed In

Michigan

Give us a call

231-330-0876

Thank You

I'll be reaching out to you shortly. In the meantime, please feel free to call or text me with any questions.

Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realtors, 420 Howard St, Petoskey, MI 49770

Contact Carol

By providing your phone number to receive this free information, you accept our Terms of Use and acknowledge your personal data will be handled in accordance with our Privacy Policy. You agree that we may contact you at the telephone number you provided, including if your number is on a Do Not Call list.